Early Access in my Playing Experience

It's not often I prepurchase a game, there hasn't been a need for it realistically; keyword, need. But, there's the opposite, Releasing a 'pre-launching' a game or early access. This isn't going to really be a good and bad or my own personal opinion on early access. I want to get into why I think early access is particularly skewed against your favor as a player. 


The promise of content

Developers and most regular people sell you nothing, so there is some game there. The amount being totally up to the developer, when published and in the future (yes, that is the case. Many games are in Early Access limbo by choice or not) . Inherently, this isn't a problem as long as the content present is complete enough and more is added eventually. What does become a problem is being acutely aware the game will stop not because it's done, but because it has nothing left to give. To clarify, I find it very intrusive when a game stops my fun and sometimes takes the satisfaction away from me, because it isn't done. 

For an example, I got Hades II on early access well before it was in a finished state. This means that the narrative was capped because certain things hadn't been added until release. I do understand that this is to prevent spoilers and not encroach on the vision of the game... Yet I think any game where the narrative is even remotely important in any degree, should generally avoid early access. Part of what made Hades special was the integration of the narrative and core rogue mechanic. To strip that narrative pay off from the end of runs was fine at first because it was fun, but for awhile I struggled to come back to the game. This is only made a little worse by it being procedural, I wouldn't know whether something is locked away or I've just not encountered it in a run. For another indie example, I really loved Alabaster Dawn's demo but because of what I experienced with Hades II, I won't be getting it until release. In fear that I might hit a digit construction site that'll be finished and I'll miss it. Maybe this is the time where I swoon over when I could hold video games in my hands and when I bought it, it'd be mine and completely finished. 

Players at Breakneck Speed


I don't think it's an insane assumption to say that people move on from games quickly. From buying a friendslop game worth pocket change only to play it for two rounds or simply buying games on sale and only thinking about clicking install. The games that do get through that barrier better fight tooth and nail for the player to play long enough to enjoy it. As mentioned with Hades II, I might have seen the game go into v1.0 but I didn't jump straight in to play it. What feels a little more criminal to me is the phenomenon where no game scratches your itch other than an unfinished early access game. The true crime is not seeing it through and letting that game before everyone to enjoy. On the flipside, I do understand that many things happen in development and it's a bit of a shame that whatever is out there of developer's hard work may never be finished. And should a game ever be finished, it might just be forgotten and neither party gets to fully see the game through. 

Where does that leave early access? It's a very context based topic, but for my general opinion; There are many genres of games that can get away with early access on a fundamental level. Yet, for overall success of your game, I personally think once it's out there in a purchasable form, most people will consider it 'done' and maybe that's the standard that should be followed. The proceeds of early access used to smooth over the tail end of development and quickly pump out the finished version for those who were unsure of it. Of course, that is a hypothetical, but all we can do is hope for and do better.  

Comments

Popular Posts