A book I've been reading and recently finished is Atomic Habits by James Clear. Recommended to me by a friend, I thought it would be an interesting read if only to be reflective of how I go about my day to day and working. The short of the book is looking into what spurs you to engage in a habit and why you continue to do it. With four laws to building a good habit, making it obvious, attractive, easy, and satisfying. Interesting in it's own right to apply to your life, but also interesting to think about within games as a strategy to retain players. I will note this is going to be applied to gacha games because they are a genre of game that really depend on this for their business model and enable a terrible habit. Also because of my own personal experience having regularly played three gacha games for at least a year.
Making it obvious: Pop-ups
Every gacha game has a daily set of repeated tasks done to get a small reward towards pulling gacha. These are often one click away and have buttons to send you directly to where the tasks are done. The UI is tailor made to the be environment where you can access everything related to the dailies. Atomic habits does suggest that in real life you tailor your/a environment for the habit you would like to do, not unlike making a UI with everything a tap away. One key factor in every gacha game is efficiency, how quickly does it take to do your daily task and how much of that is your input. Honkai Star Rail has almost stripped all the gameplay out of doing the daily tasks resulting in dailies being done in less than 10 minutes. Dailies therefore are just clicking everything with a red exclamation point and hitting collect. This also feeds into making dailies easy. For the vast majority of players, this is their interaction with the game until limited events and major updates, so putting it right in their face and making it quick is key.
Making it attractive: The chance for rewards.
Outside of the pocket change and lint given to the player for playing the game daily, the grind required to build a character is baked into doing dailies. Whatever equipment, material, resource, etc. needed to power a character up is linked to another random chance system ala ARPGs. Attributes and stats of equipment are randomized, meaning you would take multiple days by design to prep a character for use. That is unless you paid more to play the game, given gacha games all have a stamina system to cap how much you can play. The tasks within dailies usually geared towards getting you to farm for you characters, pairing something you need to do with something you would want to do. Ultimately because pulling for new characters and an accompanying augment is by nature much better than just farming for character(s) at risk of being power crept.
Making it easy: Automation and Shortcuts
It was already mentioned earlier, but the easier the tasks actually are, the more likely someone is going to actually do them. Not only in ease of access but in labor and difficulty; Once again, Honkai Star Rail allows the player to store stamina and then use it for later. Also, awarding the player with items to redeem along with the stamina to skip going into combat. This is accounted for in the dailies, heavily shaving down the time to complete dailies. On the flipside, I stopped playing games similar to Genshin Impact because I didn't feel thrilled to play the same few quests or want to prance around the map collecting flower. Or also only being able to grind certain resources on certain days. Many people who play gacha games end up playing multiple and have an alloted time in the day when they can play. Occupying less of that time but also leaving a good impression is important for a gacha game to be someone's staple. From an outside perspective, it seems to strange to remove the meat of your game from a daily basis until a major update. Personally, I think the format does need this to prevent burnout and general boredom between updates. It is still a very valid concern that not only designers would catch but players as well, seeing as they will take the path of least resistance, but won't move at all if it's uninteresting.
Making it Satisfying: Trickling Rewards
Beyond dailies, there are also limited time check in events where the rewards are much larger at the cost of consistency. A player has to login consecutively, most commonly a week. There's an immediate reward to just opening the game and then the other little rewards darted around the gameplay. Those in a bind to before the limited event before it ends, are punished for missing a day. However also with the usage of limited time, fear of missing out (FOMO) punishes though who lacking in this 'habit'. In the moment, it's rewarding working up towards more pulls and materials, but in the grand scheme of things you're trading your time for what could be bought. Gacha games do try to sweeten the deal once you return to a game, by offering some rewards for logging back in for a week. On the nose, but them expertly trying to rewire the habit back into you rather than welcoming you back nicely.
Closing Thoughts
I think it's easy to think that most of games design is fun or coming up with something fun. The overlap between areas like behavioral studies like this example. Part of what makes it hard for me to really enjoy a gacha game completely is often the design. Outside of them wanting me to habitually play the game almost daily, I find there's no real point if fundamentally something about the game is wrong. Honkai Star Rail has many gameplay and character issues that compound to the customer experience when pulling for a character. Maybe that's me having too high of an opinion for games that are in essence calculators and slot machines with pretty graphics. Or it's me realizing I have a bad habit of spending too much time on a gacha game when I could be playing other games or enjoying other media to enrich myself. Either way, it's interesting and a bit scary to think that games can have an affect like this.
Comments
Post a Comment